according to a coot that called into a radio station in Columbia on Friday. The host (fill in) seemed to concur.
So I decided to do a little research. I looked at what has happened with each school's 2006, 2007 and 2008 recruiting classes:
ESPN recruits with a score of 80 or higher from 2006 to 2007: USuC: Kenrick Ellis (2006) – Transferred Brian Maddox (2007) – Undrafted Stephen Garcia (2007) – Undrafted Mark Barnes (2007) – Transferred Joe Hills (2007) – Transferred Cliff Matthews (2007) – NFL 7th round Chris Culliver (2007) – NFL 3rd round CC Whitlock (2008) – Still on the team (despite issues) Shaq Wilson (2008) – Still on the team Out of 9 players rated 80 or higher by ESPN: 33% Transferred 22% Undrafted 22% Drafted by the NFL 23% Still on the team
Clemson: Byron Maxwell (2006) – NFL 6th round CJ Spiller (2006) – NFL 1st round Ricky Sapp (2006) – NFL 5th round Jamie Cumbie (2006) – Undrafted DeAndre McDaniel (2006) – Undrafted Willy Korn (2007) – Injured/Transferred after graduating DaQuan Bowers (2008) – NFL 2nd round Jamie Harper (2008) – NFL 4th round Kyle Parker (2008) – National Baseball Leaque Brandon Thompson (2008) – NFL 3rd round Antoine McClain (2008) – Undrafted Dwayne Allen (2008) – NFL 3rd round Tarik Rollins – Transferred Kenneth Page – Dismissed Marquan Jones – Undrafted Spencer Adams, Andre Ellington, Xavier Brewer and Tig Willard returning for 2012 Of the 19 players rated 80 or above by ESPN: 42% Drafted by the NFL/National Baseball Leaque 21% Undrafted 5% Transferred 5% Dismissed 5% Injured 22% Still on the team
* So with top players Clemson has a higher placement rate in the NFL. USuC does excel in one category - the number of top players that transfer out of their program.
I also looked at the opposite end of the spectrum – players that were unranked/unrated by ESPN at the time they were recruited but went on to the NFL. For 2006, 2007 and 2008 classes:
USuC – Had no unrated players out of high school drafted by the NFL
Clemson – Had 3 unrated players out of high school drafted by the NFL: Andre Branch, Coty Sensabaugh and Chris Hairston. In addition, while not drafted, Michael Palmer was also an unrated player out of high school who is now in the NFL.